Yelp Cincy’s Ice Cream Bucket List

After a LONG winter in Cincy (snow in APRIL – what?) we’re all ready to get out of the house and into the sunshine. And what better way to kick off summer than with a bucket list full of Cincinnati’s best ice cream shops? 

I scream, you scream, we all scream for Yelp Cincy’s Ice Cream Bucket List!
Aglamesis Bros. (pictured)

Oakley + Montgomery

A family owned ice cream and sweets shop for over 3 generations serves up premium french ice creams in their charming retail stores that will transport you back in time. Their flavors like butter pecan, coconut and dutch holland chocolate has delighted patrons with each scoop. But maybe you’re trying to stay away from dairy? Aglamesis serves up flavorful Italian Ices that are made with fresh fruits and no dairy products that result in a delicious treat even dairy lovers will enjoy!

Walker Bros. Ice Cream


Wanting to feel like you’re on vacation without leaving the Queen City? Head to Walkers Bros. Ice Cream in Montgomery! Complete with a walk-up window, a gorgeous patio, an oldies soundtrack playing over the speakers and their sweet soft-serve ice cream, you’re looking at a perfect summer night in Cincy.

Hello Honey


You won’t find another spot in Cincinnati quite like Hello Honey. They have been crafting original ice cream flavors like salted caramel, brownie & cream and bananas honeycomb since 2012 and blowing Yelpers away with their marshmallow skills. All scoops and desserts can be topped with a fresh marshmallow that is torched right in front of you (and roasted to your liking)! Talk about a “sweet” experience.

Loveland Sweets


Loveland Sweets is located right smack-dab in the middle of historic Loveland and has been serving up their house-made ice cream and sweets since 2006. Made in small batches with premium and local ingredients, you can taste the love in every bite. They even have dog ice cream for favorite furry friend!

Graeter’s Ice Cream

Multiple Locations

No ice cream bucket list in Cincinnati is complete without a “scoop” from Graeter’s Ice Cream. For over 145 years Graeter’s has kept their french pot process alive and makes their ice cream one batch at a time. There has never not been a smile when someone takes a bite of their favorite Graeter’s flavor. Tweet us your favorite flavor @yelpcincy!

For more Yelp summer favorites, check out Yelp Cincy’s Creamy Whip Bucket List!

Similar Articles



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


From our Sponsors